Timothy (Tanner Cohen) is a student in a private school who’s cast as Puck in A Midsummer Night’s Dream by his eccentric drama teacher. Studying his lines, he discovers a recipe for a secret love potion hidden in the book. Soon, in Were the World Mine, Timothy creates a magical pansy for spritzing his potion and first accidentally makes his best friend (Ricky Goldman) fall in love with him. He then proceeds to bespell the rugby player he’s got a crush on (Nathaniel David Becker), then goes on to make the entire rugby team gay. Then as the chaos mounts, he spritzes most of his small town.

1 2 ►